Vinyl vs. Gunite Pool

When planning an in ground pool, the big question is whether to go vinyl or gunite. Here are a few things to consider when making your big decision.
First, where are you putting the pool? Is it your primary residence or a second home? A pool in a beach community has more intrinsic value than one in your regular neighborhood yard. For the most part, buyers and renters at the "beach" want a pool. The same cannot be said for a pool in your primary residence and many end up being filled in. In fact, appraisers actually take off value if your home has a pool.

Second is cost. Gunite is more expensive than a vinyl pool, from 50-75% higher in some areas. If you are budget conscious and only have so much to spend, then vinyl might do the trick. On the other hand, gunite might cost more but dollar for dollar, may enhance value of your property more than vinyl can.

Third is maintenance. A vinyl pool will need it's liner replaced every 5-7 years and a liner can be punctured with something as small as a sharp toenail. Gunite needs to be re-marble dusted every 10+ years depending on calcium build up. (Side note: Use a reputable pool company to maintain your pool during summer months. Inexperienced pool guys can destroy the marble dust coating and require re-marble dust within 1-2 years.)

Lastly, focus on your vision of your pool and your likes. If you want a bluestone surround, then a vinyl pool might look a little cheesy. If pavers are your cup of tea, you could go either way. Spend the time to plan the design of your pool to come up with your dream pool and backyard landscape!

In our situation, although we were "gung-ho" for the vinyl for budget reasons, we ended up going with the gunite and I am really glad we did. Photos: Above, a Vinyl Pool. Lower, Our finished Gunite Product.